2017’s Best Electric Dog Fence for Your Best Buddy

 Best Electric Dog Fence

You cherish your dog’s freedom and space.

Still, you have to protect your dog: cars pose a considerable danger, and your neighbor may not appreciate your dog roaming in his/her yard.

Choosing a dependable electric dog fence is the right solution: it is a humane, safe way to accustom your furry companion with boundaries. Making the right choice is challenging, so we’re here to present you the answers to the most commonly met questions regarding electric dog fences as well as the top products in the category.

Top 5 Best Electric Dog Fences of 2017

Availability

Image

Model Name

Editor's Rating

Price

SportDOG Brand In-Ground Fence System

SportDOG Brand In-Ground Fence System

$$

PetSafe Wireless Fence Pet Containment System

PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System

$$

PetSafe Stay + Play Wireless Fence

PetSafe Stay + Play Wireless Fence

$$$

eXtreme Dog Fence - Second Generation In-Ground Electric Dog Fence

eXtreme Dog Fence - Second Generation

$$$

PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence

PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence

$

SportDOG Brand In-Ground Fence System

SportDOG brand was created in 2003 by Radio Systems Corporation, the same parent company that owns brands like PetSafe and Invisible Fence Brand. Their goal was to develop products that would stand up to the harshest conditions such as those encountered by hunters and their canine companions.

Since then SportDOG has gone on to produce the SDF-100A in-ground fence – a top notch system with a fully waterproof collar that’s second to none when it comes to durability.

SportDOG Brand In-Ground Fence System

There are numerous types of fences for dogs. One of them is an in-ground pet fence system. This product might be the best invisible dog fence for you considering the features it presents.

It has the highest range of coverage – up to 100 acres. So, this pet fence is fitted for people who have large properties and live in rural communities.

You can use it with multiple dogs if you buy an extra SDF-R receiver. As a proud owner of more than one dog, this may be a decent choice. The collar is 100 percent waterproof and ranks high regarding durability.

It is fitted for dogs that weigh over 10 pounds. Also, the system is featured by an anti-linger function.

What does this entail? This function is meant to deter your pet from draining the battery intentionally. Also, the system presents audible and visual wire break alarm in case anything happens to the electric pet fence.This feature boosts the safety of the system.

PROS

  • check
    Well-defined, clear containment perimeter
  • check
    Varied compatible collars
  • check
    Durability

CONS

  • times-circle
    Wire coming off the spools when unwrapping

PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System

The PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System PIF-300 has definitely stood the test of time. No matter how many electric dog fences hit the market, this PetSafe wireless fence continues to earn top rating year in and year out.

In addition to it being a very cost effective alternative to a traditional above ground fencing, with no wires bury you can have this portable dog fence up and running in less than an hour.

PetSafe Wireless Fence Pet Containment System

Since 1991 PetSafe has been setting the bar high when it comes to pet containment systems, both wireless and in-ground. Their love of animals and dedication to helping pet owners is reinforced by their ongoing commitment to safe pet products and top notch customer satisfaction.

This detailed review will tell you everything you need to know about the PIF-300, including how the key components work, how to install it and what other consumers think about this portable pet fence.

Although it’s not right for every type of yard, when you combine it's quick easy setup and complete portability with a solid dependable system that’s packed with safety features, it’s tough to find another wireless fence under $300 that offers more value for your money!

If you’re looking for a safe and effective pet containment system that you can take with you when you travel and can have up and running in less than an hour no matter where you are, the PIF-300’s track record makes it worthy of some serious consideration.

The PetSafe PIF-300 is incredibly popular and the vast majority of reviews are overwhelmingly positive with a huge volume of extremely satisfied dog owners.

I spent many hours researching the Petsafe wireless fence reviews for the PIF-300 to get an overall feeling for why people either like it or don’t like it.

PROS

  • check
    Quick setup
  • check
    Easy to use
  • check
    Completely portable

CONS

  • times-circle
    Limited to a circular shaped boundary
  • times-circle
    Boundary is inconsistent

PetSafe Stay + Play Wireless Fence

The PetSafe PIF00-12917 Stay And Play Wireless Fence is the newest wireless dog fence from PetSafe.

A step up from its predecessor, the PIF-300, among other things it offers a larger coverage area, a rechargeable collar and it’s safe and effective for smaller dogs.

With no wires to bury, you’ll enjoy a quick hassle free installation that will have your fence up and running in less than an hour. 

PetSafe Stay + Play Wireless Fence

And the Stay and Play offers complete portability which means that you can use it to contain your dog anywhere, anytime!

PetSafe has been around since 1991 and they are committed to providing you with the best possible products for your pets. Time and again the reviews mention their excellent customer service and willingness to go above and beyond to make their customers happy.

The Stay + Play Wireless Fence definitely offers significant improvements over the PIF-300. Designed with convenience in mind, it has a smaller transmitter and a rechargeable collar that’s small enough to be comfortable on dogs as tiny as 5 lbs.

On top of that, you get a system that can accommodate an unlimited number of dogs, has multiple compatible collars and is completely portable. When you add it all up, the Stay and Play is a solid reliable wireless pet fence that’s definitely worth a long hard look.

Without a doubt two of the most loved features of the 12917 are its quick easy setup and the fact that it’s a portable dog fence.

Time and again users said that you just can’t beat being able to throw this fence into your vehicle and use it to provide a safe and effective containment area for your pooch no matter where your travels take you.

PROS

  • check
    Over Correction Protection
  • check
    Low battery warning light
  • check
    Very low ongoing maintenance
  • check
    Completely portable

CONS

  • times-circle
    Fluctuating boundary line
  • times-circle
    Random shocks (infrequent)

eXtreme Dog Fence - Second Generation In-Ground Electric Dog Fence

The Professional Dog Fence | Extreme Dog Fence System utilizes wires buried underground to mark a boundary for your pet, so this will create a more accurate boundary compared to the wireless system. The system is capable of encircling an area of up to 10 acres and making it safe for your dog.

The receiver collar is lightweight, having a weight of only 1.1 oz., has a five level static correction and is waterproof.

eXtreme Dog Fence - Second Generation In-Ground Electric Dog Fence

The transmitter included in the system has an easy-to-read digital display, and in the event of a thunderstorm, the included surge protector will protect the transmitter from a power surge that may be caused by a lightning strike.

The 500 ft. of wire provided with the system is enough to cover 1/3 of an acre of land, and is coated with polyethylene to make it weatherproof. You can purchase additional wire if you want to increase the area of protection, and also additional collars if you want to provide protection to more than one dog.

The underground fencing kit also includes 50 ft. of twisted wire and 2 waterproof splices. The included 50 boundary flags and a training DVD will aid you in training your dog properly so that you can make proper use of the system in protecting your dog.

You can be rest assured of the quality of all these products as all of them are made in the USA.

PROS

  • check
    Sturdy, well-made product
  • check
    Easy installation
  • check
    Waterproof

CONS

  • times-circle
    Heavy
  • times-circle
    The system isn’t rechargeable

PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence

Is your dog as stubborn as the day is long? Have you tried pretty much everything to keep him in the yard and still somehow he manages to escape? Then the PetSafe PIG00-10777 Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence may be the ideal solution for you!

The Stubborn Dog Fence has the largest and strongest receiver collar on the market and hundreds of users agree that it’s one of the most effective collars for all those tough to train and difficult to contain dogs.

PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence

The higher intensity correction levels are delivered at about twice the strength of regular collars and that’s why they get the attention of dogs with a high tolerance to pain or breeds that are notoriously stubborn.

The PetSafe PIG00-10777 Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence was created for very stubborn or really large dogs that need stronger correction levels than a regular receiver collar can deliver.

While the higher intensity correction levels would overwhelm small or timid dogs, they’re extremely effective at recapturing the attention of even the largest, most difficult to train persistent pooches.

I love to read stories about people who have been able to solve a big problem with a great product and the reviews on the PetSafe Stubborn Dog are chalk full of those types of stories!

Without a doubt, the overwhelming majority of people using this underground fence for dogs absolutely love it.

But what struck me the most was how many people went from thinking nothing in the world would work on their dog to being completely satisfied by how effectively the 10777 contained their furry friend.

Whether their dog was a digger, a jumper, a master escape artist, a chaser or just one of those dogs who says “I’m big and I don’t want to listen to you”, time and again the Stubborn Dog worked like a charm!

PROS

  • check
    Can be used with other PetSafe collars
  • check
    Run Through Prevention
  • check
    Safety Time Out
  • check
    Anti Linger Prevention
  • check
    Low battery warning indicator

CONS

  • times-circle
    Too strong for dogs under about 20 lbs
  • times-circle
    Collar strap wears out too quickly
  • times-circle
    Collar is non rechargeable
  • times-circle
    No pre-installed battery backup for transmitter

How Do Electric Dog Fences Work?

Electric dog fence systems consist of a wire that is buried several inches deep. The dog also has to wear a collar.

Here’s what happens:

A transmitter based in your basement or garage delivers a signal to the receiver collar. When the dog gets close to the perimeter, the collar beeps a signal. When your pet gets overly close to the fence, it receives a mild shock. The effect the shock has on the dog isn’t severe.

The question that imminently follows is, do electric fences work as in aiding your dog in learning those boundaries? When combined with consistent training, we consider that this practice might bring positive results.

This practice reinforces in your dog’s mind that it should stay at a distance from the barrier. We believe that voice and leash training is crucial in all aspects, this included.

Bear in mind, however, that your pet should be at least six months of age. It should be acquainted with basic commands.

Why Get the Best Electric Dog Fence for Your Dogs?

For starters, electric fencing for dogs is a great option if you want to limit your dog to a particular area. Some dogs can get easily bored, which triggers them to explore its environs.

Also, allowing your dog to roam exposes your pet to a series of dangers, such as getting injured, attacked or lost. On that note, statistics indicate that, in the US, about 1.2 million dogs die in car accidents.

That isn’t the best scenario considering that your dog is helpless in front of a speeding car, for instance. Living with such thoughts is stressful.

When you choose a product that is specifically tailored to your dog’s needs, the results are consistent. Make sure you factor in your dog’s weight, stubbornness and coat thickness.

Best Electric Dog Fence: Pros and Cons

One common question that most owners ask themselves is the following: are electric dog fences safe? This issue is entirely explainable:

Knowing the advantages and disadvantages of a wireless pet fence is crucial to your pet’s well-being.

These are our pros:

  • check-circle
    Numerous neighborhoods are restrictive when it comes to traditional fencing systems. (This is one of the reasons behind the popularity of electric dog fences.)
  • check-circle
    Careless people often happen to leave the gate open, which may expose your pet to unnecessary dangers.
  • check-circle
    The best electric fence for dogs is storm proof. If your dog gets in contact with water, it won’t be electrocuted.

Cons:

  • times-circle
    Vocal training is still necessary.

Top Things to Look for in the Best Electric Dog Fence

How much area can it cover?

The transmitter is the component that determines how much area an electric fence can cover. While some transmitters can only cover 1 acre, others are powerful enough to cover 25 acres or more.

Here are some things to take into account when considering your choices:

Wireless systems:

  • chevron-right
    Are limited to a circular shaped boundary which means they’re not the best choice if you have an odd or rectangular shaped yard
  • chevron-right
    Are only effective in smaller areas — generally less than 5 acres
  • chevron-right
    Don’t work well on steeply sloped landscapes or properties with lots of obstructions such as heavily wooded areas

In-ground systems:

  • chevron-right
    Can be completely customized to whatever size and shape you want
  • chevron-right
    Can cover areas from 5-100+ acres
  • chevron-right
    Are effective on any type of landscape or terrain
  • chevron-right
    Can be used not only to keep your dog inside a set perimeter but also to keep them out of off limits areas such as a pool, garden or flowerbed

What’s involved in the installation process?

Wireless systems are quick and easy to set up — you can easily have one up and running in less than an hour.

In-ground fences take more time and elbow grease to install. Depending on the area that needs to be covered you’re looking at anywhere from 1-2 days.

One thing to keep in mind with either type of electronic pet containment system is that they can both be used in conjunction with an above ground fence. For example, many people stopped their dog from digging under or jumping over a wood or chain link fence by attaching their boundary wire to it.

What size dog can it be used on?

The receiver collar is without a doubt one of the most important things to consider when buying either type of electric dog fence.

In order for your dog to be comfortable while wearing the collar it’s important to consider these 2 things:

  • chevron-right
    How big is the receiver unit?
  • chevron-right
    How much does it weigh?

Although there are a huge variety of collars available that can be used on dogs from as small as 5 lbs all the way up to 250+ lbs, one of the things I want to caution you on is that you can’t always trust the manufacturer’s recommendation.

On more than a few occasions, I found that what the manufacturer recommended was very different than what people using the system recommended.

For example, PetSafe says that their Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence system is good for any dog over 8lbs. However, because the collar that comes with this fence is one of the largest and heaviest on the market the vast majority of consumer reviews suggest that most people are using it on dogs in the 50-200 lb range.

Conclusion: So Is An Electric Dog Fence Right For You?

We all love our dogs and want them to keep them safe in our yard and out of harm’s way. Although electric dog fences may not be right in every circumstance, as you can see they are perfect in many situations.

Now that you know where they should and shouldn’t be used and the 2 main types of fences, you’re well armed to make the decision to either join the bandwagon and buy an electric dog fence or find an alternative solution for your dog fencing needs.